A northern fjord seen from a high viewpoint, a small white village on the far shore.

Arkon GroupIndustry perspective

Business Services: the margin is won in the proposal and kept after signing

Business services firms that price by what is at stake, hold one discount line and bill every change after signing keep the margin their people earn. Those that sell hours and accept scope creep give it away.

Arkon Group perspective · updated 23 October 2026

Consulting, managed services, outsourced operations, staffing and technology-enabled services all sell the time and judgement of skilled people. The commercial problem is the same across them. Margin slips at four points: when work that matters is priced like work that does not, when discounts are agreed one deal at a time, when scope grows after signing without a bill, and when partner selling time goes to proposals that were never likely to win. None of these needs a new strategy. Each needs a rule, a measure and the discipline to read the measure correctly before acting on it.

Framework

Price the work by what is at stake, not by the hour it takes

Clients pay for the consequence of the work. A restructuring, a regulatory deadline or a process that would be painful to move away from carries a different value from extra capacity on a known task. Firms that price both on one rate card undercharge the first and lose the second on price. The aim is to separate them deliberately.

  • What good looks like: the gap widens between the realised rate on high-stakes work and on capacity work, and the win rate on capacity proposals rises.
  • In outsourced operations, the same logic applies to how hard a process is to move. The harder the switch, the less the price should look like a commodity rate.
  • What to watch: if capacity proposals are lost on the team offered rather than the rate, a lower rate will not win them. The offer and the proof of performance need work instead.

Trend

Most leakage happens after the price is agreed

The rate card is rarely the problem. The realised rate is. Three rules close most of the gap between what was quoted and what was collected.

  • One discount policy: the realised rate stays close to the rate card within each client group, and every write-off is explained by a named reason. If one client dominates fees, apply the limit to the rest of the book.
  • Bill scope added after signing: overrun on fixed-price work goes through change orders, short-notice requests are priced, and write-offs fall. If the overrun comes from proposals that were under-estimated, the fix is better estimating at the proposal stage, not tougher billing.
  • Rates that follow pay: every agreement longer than a year sits on a named index, and rates move within a quarter of that index moving. Public clients may write their own index into the tender, so the clause follows theirs.

Framework

Write a small number of offers, each with a proof and a price logic

Most firms write every proposal from scratch. That makes proposals expensive to produce and inconsistent in what they promise. The better model is a short set of written offers. Each is built for a defined client group, carries evidence of results and states how it is priced. Repeatable work is then proposed from a standard offer.

  • What good looks like: the win rate rises in the segments the richer offer is written for, cost to serve falls where the offer is lean, and proposal hours per win fall.
  • For retainer and managed services, the offer has to show continuity and results, not only a list of services.
  • What to watch: if losses are head-to-head on features rather than continuity, the richer offer must prove performance, not service. If every assignment is genuinely different, keep the standard offers few and rely on a firm gate for deciding which proposals to write.

Framework

Spend partner selling time where the fees are

Partner and senior selling time is the scarcest commercial resource in the firm. It tends to spread across every open opportunity. It should go first to the largest clients and to sponsors who are actively buying. Outside reach through partners and brokers is useful, but only when it is paid for results.

  • What good looks like: most partner selling time goes to the largest clients and live sponsors, proposals per win fall, and fees per selling hour rise.
  • Report proposal flow from partners and brokers by client group every month. Pay fees only on work they bring, and cover the largest clients with your own partners.
  • What to watch: if your consultants are fully booked, broker work pushes out better work and the extra reach is worth less. If most work arrives through public tenders written to a fixed format, focus moves to choosing which tenders are worth writing.

Trend

Know why you lose, and what each client costs to win and serve

Two records separate firms that improve from firms that guess. The first is the reason behind every lost proposal, set against a standing comparison with the firms you meet in competition. The second is each client's margin after the cost to win and serve them.

  • Close the capability gaps that lose proposals, and check that losses on capability fall after each gap is closed. If proposals are mostly lost on the rate, pricing and the offer come first.
  • Grow service lines per client, and report every month the fees from services launched in the last three years. If clients buy the other service under a framework you are not on, the opportunity is smaller than it looks.
  • Hand over the tail of clients below the margin threshold each year. The exception is a small client that opens the door to a large group. Keep that client and price the work properly.

So what

Diagnose the cause before you pull the lever

Every rule above comes with a reading that changes the answer. A win-rate problem may be a team problem. An overrun may be an estimating problem. Broker reach may cost more than it brings if consultants are already fully booked. Leaders who act on the headline measure often fix the wrong thing. The useful questions are specific.

  • Are we losing on rate, on the team we offer, or on capability? The answer decides whether pricing, the offer or the portfolio moves first.
  • Is our realised rate drifting because of discounts, unbilled scope or rates that lag the index?
  • Is partner selling time concentrated on the clients and sponsors that produce the fees?

How Arkon helps

Where Arkon fits

Arkon turns these rules into a working view of your own firm, kept current monthly. Commercial Strategy sets where the firm competes and which client groups deserve the richer offer. Pricing separates high-stakes work from capacity work, sets one discount policy, and puts change orders and index clauses in place so the quoted rate becomes the collected rate. Go-to-Market builds the written offers, the proposal gate and the partner time allocation, and tracks win rate, proposal hours per win and fees per selling hour. Each module can be activated on its own and in any order.